Home›Bar Review›2022›Criminal Law›Question 4
Question 4
4. Bernardo, a mayoralty candidate of Osram City, wanted to eliminate Yori, his political opponent. Yori announced his intention to run for mayor of the same city. A month before the filing of candidacy, Bernardo and Benjamin met at a hotel and discussed their plan to kill Yori on the day when he would file his certificate of candidacy. Based on their agreement, Bernardo would provide the guns and the money, while Benjamin would provide the personnel to cordon off all roads leading to the COMELEC’s local office.
On the day of the execution of the plan, however, Benjamin flew to Manila to avoid being involved in the planned killing of Yori. Bernardo, determined to kill Yori, convened his own armed group and laid out a new plan to kill Yori, and in accordance with it, his armed group patrolled all the roads leading to the COMELEC’s local office. Bernardo remained in his house and monitored the execution of the plan from there. As soon as Yori and his supporters passed by the main road at around 2:00 p.m., Bernardo’s armed group opened fire at them. Yori was unharmed as he was inside a bulletproof vehicle, but ten of his supporters were killed. Bernardo, the members of his armed group, and Benjamin were later charged with ten counts of Murder for the death of Yori’s supporters and one count of Attempted Murder of Yori.
Discuss the criminal liability for the crimes charged against each of the following: (i) Bernardo, (ii) the members of Bernardo’s armed group, and (iii) Benjamin. Explain briefly. (5 points)
Model answer · ALAC
Answer — Legal basis — Application — Conclusion.
AI-drafted in ALAC form and AI-verified against landmark authorities — refined with every round of verification.