Home›Bar Review›2022›Mercantile Law›Question 4
Question 4
4. At around 4:00 p.m. of December 25, 2020, Christmas Day, Queenie and her child, Paeng, boarded a jeepney being operated by Emil and driven by Amor. Queenie was made to sit on an empty beer case at the edge of the rear entrance/exit of the jeepney with her sleeping child on her lap. When they reached an uphill incline on the road, the jeepney slid backwards. Queenie pushed both her feet against the step board to prevent herself and her child from being thrown out of the exit, but because the step board was wet, her left foot slipped and was crushed between the step board and the coconut tree which halted the jeepney’s backward motion. As a result, Queenie’s leg was badly injured and had to be amputated.
Queenie then sued Emil and Amor for breach of contract of carriage. Emil and Amor countered that the injuries Queenie sustained were due to her own fault since Amor had instructed everyone not to panic, but Queenie nevertheless tried to disembark which caused her foot to be crushed
If you were the judge, would you hold Emil and Amor solidarily liable? Explainbriefly. (5 points)
Model answer · ALAC
Answer — Legal basis — Application — Conclusion.
AI-drafted in ALAC form and AI-verified against landmark authorities — refined with every round of verification.