Home›Bar Review›2023›Criminal Law›Question 8
Question 8
8. Samuel, a Filipino citizen of Chinese descent, assisted the Chinese Government
in surveying and determining the safest and most secure shores in the Philippines.
He thought he was helping the Philippines in this endeavor since the geodetic
maps he prepared would allegedly be transmitted to the Philippines for future
use. Before the survey was completed, Chinese military vessels entered the
Philippines’ Scarborough shores, set up a station secured by two warships, and
populated two islets which the Chinese Government proclaimed as their own, all
with the use of the geodetic maps. Samuel was then charged with Treason by the
Philippine Government. The following testified against Samuel: 1) his helper,
Therese, who saw Samuel in numerous meetings with the Chinese Government,
though she did not understand their conversations since she does not know
Chinese; and 2) his gardener, Rolando, who knows Chinese but has bad eyesight.
Rolando was present in all these meetings and had a glimpse of the finished
geodetic maps signed by Samuel. Is Samuel liable for Treason? Explain.
Model answer · ALAC
Answer — Legal basis — Application — Conclusion.
AI-drafted in ALAC form and AI-verified against landmark authorities — refined with every round of verification.