Home›Bar Review›2025›Labor Law›Question 7
Question 7
7. XYZ Gym engaged A, B, and C as fitness trainers. They were paid fixed monthly
salaries, commissions, and other statutory benefits. After two years, XYZ Gym
reclassified them as freelance trainers. While they were still paid monthly salaries
and commissions, the other statutory benefits were discontinued. A, B, and C
opposed their reclassification, claiming they are regular employees since their work
is essential to the business of XYZ Gym. However, XYZ Gym maintained that as
freelance trainers, they are deemed to be independent contractors and their
engagement by the company was only in consideration of their skill and expertise.
Decide with reason(s).
Model answer · ALAC
Answer — Legal basis — Application — Conclusion.
AI-drafted in ALAC form and AI-verified against landmark authorities — refined with every round of verification.